Control Design Attributes Must Be Satisfied for the Control to Be Effective.

The Control Design Attributes are the criteria for an internal control over financial reporting (ICFR) to be “effective” (as in SOX 404).

Common Attributes are:

The authority (approved by the Board) is properly delegated to the control owner (e.g., review manager, etc.). (Note that the authority should not delegated to a non-manager staff or a personnel who is not part of management.)

The control owner manager is adequately competent to operate his/her ICFR (so that s/he can fulfill their accountability delegated).

The ICFR mitigates relevant Inherent (misstatement) Risk defined at an Assertion (e.g., existence/occurrence, completeness, valuation/measurement, presentation/disclosure) level.

Segregation of Duties (SoD) is in place.

ITGC is effective (if an IT(/IT dependent manual) control).

Each Attribute is required by relevant COSO (2013) Principles and typically satisfied if related entity-level controls (ELCs) are “present” (as in COSO) and evidenced by applicable Policies and Procedures (and Roles and Responsibilities for the Competence Attribute) unless the Attribute is concerned with a specific process and the evidence needs to back up the process specifically: e.g., each risk remediation at an Assertion level, SoD.

Note that the above discussion is applicable to preventive ICFRs and NOT to detective ones, which are not designed at a critical data-path, or Likely Source of Potential Misstatement (LSPM as in Auditing Standard No. 5), but at a point in time whenever management sees fits.